I started reading The Hunger Games by Suzanne Collins after reading reviews by several Christian bloggers whom I respect. My daughter was interested in the series as well, so I'm reading it more as a worldview chaperone than for the story itself.
This is a departure from my usual fiction reading. For years, I stuck to "safe" books - characters and story lines with more-or-less black and white morality and all loose ends neatly tied in a bow by the end of the book, which of course must have a happy ending. I was also a card-carrying fear monger, so there was the "Oh no! It could happen to me!" motive in avoiding anything nasty that could lodge in my memory bank as potential irrational monger-fodder. But my theology has changed, which has changed me. (Thanks be to God!) Yes, there are nasty things in books and even nastier things in the real life, but I belong to a God who rules over all things, which cannot move an inch unless He decrees it. Whether I like to admit it or not, the nastiness also resides in my own heart as a sinner, not just between the pages of a book or newspaper.
As a Christian parent, there's also the consideration of what is appropriate reading material for my child. Opening the flood gates is unwise but so is unnecessary censorship. I won't help my daughter face the reality of living in a sinful world by being over-protective unless I plan to keep her in a bunker for the rest of her life. The book of Judges has some pretty horrendous accounts, so would I dare edit the Bible?
I have mixed impressions of The Hunger Games so far. I don't want to allegorize it to death in an attempt to wring out some sort of Christian sub-story that was never the author's intent. Neither do I want to discount the value of reading it because of the plot's violence. So with the risk of dissecting the book to death, this will be a good opportunity to analyze its worldview and consider issues such as total depravity, the shallowness and influence of the entertainment culture, expediency for the sake of survival, etc. Not exactly a bouquet of heart-warming fuzzies, but discussing these harsh realities with an open Bible may be more profitable than a happy ending.
This is a departure from my usual fiction reading. For years, I stuck to "safe" books - characters and story lines with more-or-less black and white morality and all loose ends neatly tied in a bow by the end of the book, which of course must have a happy ending. I was also a card-carrying fear monger, so there was the "Oh no! It could happen to me!" motive in avoiding anything nasty that could lodge in my memory bank as potential irrational monger-fodder. But my theology has changed, which has changed me. (Thanks be to God!) Yes, there are nasty things in books and even nastier things in the real life, but I belong to a God who rules over all things, which cannot move an inch unless He decrees it. Whether I like to admit it or not, the nastiness also resides in my own heart as a sinner, not just between the pages of a book or newspaper.
As a Christian parent, there's also the consideration of what is appropriate reading material for my child. Opening the flood gates is unwise but so is unnecessary censorship. I won't help my daughter face the reality of living in a sinful world by being over-protective unless I plan to keep her in a bunker for the rest of her life. The book of Judges has some pretty horrendous accounts, so would I dare edit the Bible?
I have mixed impressions of The Hunger Games so far. I don't want to allegorize it to death in an attempt to wring out some sort of Christian sub-story that was never the author's intent. Neither do I want to discount the value of reading it because of the plot's violence. So with the risk of dissecting the book to death, this will be a good opportunity to analyze its worldview and consider issues such as total depravity, the shallowness and influence of the entertainment culture, expediency for the sake of survival, etc. Not exactly a bouquet of heart-warming fuzzies, but discussing these harsh realities with an open Bible may be more profitable than a happy ending.
One of my aunts recommended to my daughter that she should read it. I am not so sure of course, but I look forward to your review.
ReplyDeleteI do believe your daughter is older than mine, though, so mine still may be too young for it.
I currently have her reading The Fellowship of the Ring,, which I haven't read (though I saw the movies) but my hubby thought it would be okay for her.
My daughter loved the whole Lord of the Rings trilogy. It's very intense at times but very satisfying at the end.
DeleteI'll let you know what I think of Hunger Games.
Glad to hear you guys are giving Collins a try, Persis. :) The books aren't perfect, but they proved to me that modern YA fiction can be thoughtful and mature. Lots of rough themes to wrestle with, but it's all more than worthwhile IMHO. Looking forward to hearing your further thoughts on it! :D
ReplyDeleteYour review was one of the ones that convinced me THG might be worth reading, Corey. I want to get past the old school view of rating things purely on the number of objectionable items rather than seeing the worldview that's being portrayed.
DeletePersis,
ReplyDeleteEven if you end up not liking the books, I think you'll be glad to have gone through them with L.
"Not exactly a bouquet of heart-warming fuzzies, but discussing these harsh realities with an open Bible may be more profitable than a happy ending." Love that!!
Have you read this, Trisha?
DeleteNo. Ink went through this series with his Dad. It's on my list, though. :)
DeleteWe can't shelter our children forever, so it's far better to explore harsh realities than to ignore them. I look forward to more of your insights. Blessings!
ReplyDeleteI agree, Petra. Over-sheltering can be an easy-out because it doesn't require discernment on anyone's part.
DeleteI read this passage in Notes from the Tilt-A-Whirl, and I thought it went quite well with what you said in your post:
ReplyDelete"The world is rated R, and no one is checking IDs. Do not try to make it G by imagining the shadows away. Do not try to hide your children from the world forever, but do not try to pretend there is no danger. Train them. Give them sharp eyes and bellies full of laughter. Make them dangerous. Make them yeast, and when they've grown, they will pollute the shadows."
I love this quote! Ink wouldn't let me have the book long enough to copy it down. LOL!
DeleteWow! Thanks for sharing this quote, Ink.
Delete